SCHD vs CD Ladder Calculator

Compare dividend growth investing with SCHD against a CD ladder strategy

Calculator Parameters

Investment Details

$10,000
$1,000 $500,000
5 years
1 year 30 years
2.5%
0% 10%

SCHD Investment Parameters

3.91%
1.00% 6.00%
7.0%
0% 15%
Historical 5-yr average: ~11.44%
5.0%
0% 15%
15%
0% 40%
Use 0% for tax-advantaged accounts

CD Ladder Parameters

4.85%
1% 8%
4.60%
1% 8%
4.35%
1% 8%
4.25%
1% 8%
4.15%
1% 8%
24%
0% 40%
Use 0% for tax-advantaged accounts

Comparison Results

Investment Summary

Initial Investment: $10,000.00
Time Horizon: 5 years
Reinvestment: Enabled
Inflation-Adjusted: Yes (2.5%)

End of Period Results

SCHD Investment

Final Value: $13,380.25
Total Return: +33.80%
Annual Income (Year 5): $547.69
Yield on Cost: 5.48%
Total Income Generated: $2,273.46
After-Tax Income: $1,932.44

CD Ladder

Final Value: $12,410.83
Total Return: +24.11%
Annual Income (Year 5): $435.68
Effective Yield: 4.36%
Total Income Generated: $2,175.89
After-Tax Income: $1,653.68

Strategy Comparison

Value Difference: +$969.42 for SCHD
Income Difference: +$112.01 for SCHD
Risk Level:
SCHD: Higher CD: Lower

Based on your inputs, SCHD outperforms the CD ladder over this 5-year period, providing 9.7% more value and 5.2% more income. However, SCHD comes with higher volatility risk while the CD ladder offers principal protection and guaranteed returns.

Value Growth
Income Comparison
Risk Analysis

Year-by-Year Analysis

Year SCHD Value SCHD Income CD Value CD Income Difference

Understanding SCHD Investment

SCHD (Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF) is a popular exchange-traded fund that focuses on high-quality dividend-paying stocks with a strong record of consistent dividend payments and growth.

Key Features of SCHD:

  • Focuses on companies with strong financial fundamentals
  • Requires at least 10 years of dividend payment history
  • Low expense ratio (0.06%)
  • Quarterly dividend payments
  • Historical dividend growth averaging ~11.44% over 5 years
  • Diversified across multiple sectors

Pros of SCHD Investment:

  • Growth potential: Both share price and dividend income can increase over time
  • Inflation hedge: Growing dividends help offset inflation impact
  • Tax advantages: Qualified dividends taxed at lower rates than ordinary income
  • Liquidity: Can be bought/sold any market day without penalties

Cons of SCHD Investment:

  • Market risk: Subject to price fluctuations and potential loss of principal
  • Dividend uncertainty: Future dividend increases not guaranteed
  • Sector concentration: May have higher exposure to certain sectors
  • No principal guarantee: Value can decline in market downturns

Understanding CD Ladder Strategy

A CD ladder is an investment strategy that involves dividing your money among multiple Certificates of Deposit (CDs) with staggered maturity dates, allowing for more frequent access to your funds while maximizing interest rates.

How a CD Ladder Works:

In a typical 5-year CD ladder, you divide your investment into five equal parts and invest in 1-year, 2-year, 3-year, 4-year, and 5-year CDs. When the 1-year CD matures, you reinvest it in a new 5-year CD, and repeat this process as each CD matures, creating a perpetual ladder.

Pros of CD Ladder Strategy:

  • Principal protection: FDIC insurance up to $250,000 per depositor, per bank
  • Guaranteed returns: Fixed interest rates provide predictable income
  • Liquidity planning: Staggered maturities provide regular access to portions of your funds
  • Lower volatility: Not subject to market fluctuations
  • Simplicity: Easy to understand and implement

Cons of CD Ladder Strategy:

  • Lower growth potential: Typically lower returns than equity investments like SCHD
  • Interest rate risk: May lock in lower rates before interest rates rise
  • Inflation risk: Fixed returns may not keep pace with inflation
  • Early withdrawal penalties: Accessing funds before maturity typically incurs penalties
  • Less tax-efficient: Interest taxed as ordinary income, not qualified dividends

When to Choose Each Strategy

Consider SCHD When:

  • You have a longer time horizon (7+ years) to ride out market volatility
  • Growth is a primary objective, not just current income
  • You're concerned about inflation eroding your purchasing power
  • You're investing in tax-advantaged accounts or benefit from qualified dividend tax rates
  • You can tolerate some market volatility and don't need guaranteed returns
  • You want to build a growing income stream that increases over time

Real-World Example: An investor with 15 years until retirement who wants to build a growing income stream that outpaces inflation while potentially benefiting from capital appreciation.

Consider CD Ladder When:

  • Capital preservation is your top priority and you cannot risk any loss of principal
  • You have a shorter time horizon (less than 5 years) for your investment
  • You need predictable income with no fluctuation in payment amounts
  • Interest rates are high or expected to decline in the near future
  • You're approaching a financial goal where you'll need the money soon
  • Market volatility makes you extremely uncomfortable or anxious

Real-World Example: An investor saving for a home down payment in 3 years who needs certainty that their principal will be available when needed, regardless of market conditions.

Hybrid Strategy: Combining SCHD and CD Ladders

Many investors can benefit from combining both strategies to balance growth potential with capital preservation and income stability. Here are several approaches to creating a hybrid strategy:

Barbell Approach

Allocate a portion of your portfolio to SCHD for growth and another portion to a CD ladder for stability and guaranteed income. This provides both upside potential and downside protection.

Suggested Split: 60% SCHD / 40% CDs

Time Segmentation

Allocate near-term funds (0-5 years) to CD ladders for safety and predictable income, while investing longer-term funds (5+ years) in SCHD for growth potential and inflation protection.

Strategy Type: Time-Based Allocation

Income Floor

Use CDs to create a guaranteed "income floor" that covers essential expenses, then invest remaining funds in SCHD for growth and discretionary spending needs.

Priority: Needs vs. Wants

Rising Rate Strategy

In a rising interest rate environment, temporarily increase CD ladder allocation to capture higher rates, while maintaining a core SCHD position for long-term growth.

Best When: Rates Increasing

Age-Based Allocation

Use your age as a guideline for CD allocation (e.g., 60 years old = 60% in CDs, 40% in SCHD), gradually shifting toward more safety as you age.

Adjustment: Annual Rebalancing

Volatility Buffer

Use CD ladder returns as a cash buffer to prevent having to sell SCHD shares during market downturns, allowing time for recovery and continued dividend growth.

Focus: Risk Management

Key Consideration for Hybrid Strategies

When implementing a hybrid approach, consider these important factors:

  • Tax implications of each investment type and optimal account placement
  • Current interest rate environment and dividend yield spread
  • Your personal risk tolerance and time horizon
  • Need for liquidity vs. long-term growth
  • Regular rebalancing to maintain desired allocation

Frequently Asked Questions

Which provides better protection against inflation: SCHD or a CD ladder?
How do taxes impact the comparison between SCHD and CD ladders?
How does the current interest rate environment affect this comparison?
Can I withdraw my money early from both investments if needed?
How do SCHD and CD ladders compare during market downturns?

Related Calculators

SCHD Dividend Reinvestment

See how dividend reinvestment can accelerate your wealth growth with SCHD over time.

Use Calculator

SCHD vs JEPI Calculator

Compare the performance and income potential of SCHD and JEPI ETFs with custom inputs.

Use Calculator

SCHD Income Replacement

Calculate how much to invest in SCHD to replace your current income in retirement.

Use Calculator