Analyze how SCHD performs during economic downturns and market stress periods
Maximum Drawdown
-32.1%
Recovery Time
1.7 Years
Dividend Reduction
-14.5%
3Y Total Return
+25.7%
Key Insight
SCHD's focus on quality companies with strong balance sheets, consistent dividend histories, and cash flow stability typically provides better downside protection during market downturns compared to the broader market.
While SCHD was launched in October 2011 (after the 2008-2009 financial crisis), we can analyze how its underlying methodology and component stocks performed during previous economic downturns.
During the COVID-19 market crash in Q1 2020, SCHD experienced:
The ETF's quality factor screening helped it recover more quickly than many high-yield but lower-quality dividend ETFs.
During the late 2018 market correction, SCHD demonstrated:
This period highlighted SCHD's defensive characteristics during short-term market stress.
Though SCHD didn't exist during the 2008-2009 financial crisis, we can analyze how its current methodology would have performed using backtested data:
Note: Backtested data has inherent limitations as it doesn't account for market conditions, liquidity issues, or other factors that could have affected actual performance.
SCHD's methodology focuses on companies with strong cash flows, manageable debt levels, and consistent dividend histories. These quality factors typically provide better downside protection during market stress.
Companies with 10+ years of dividend payments (a SCHD requirement) tend to maintain their dividends even during economic downturns, providing income stability when other sources may be cut.
SCHD's focus on quality dividends naturally leads to higher allocations in traditionally defensive sectors like consumer staples, healthcare, and utilities, which often outperform during economic contractions.
| Metric | SCHD (Average) | S&P 500 (Average) | Impact on Recession Performance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debt-to-Equity Ratio | 1.2 | 1.6 | Lower leverage helps weather liquidity challenges |
| Dividend Payout Ratio | 45% | 53% | More sustainable dividends during profit declines |
| Return on Equity | 22.7% | 19.4% | Higher profitability provides earnings buffer |
| Free Cash Flow Yield | 4.8% | 3.5% | Stronger cash generation during revenue contractions |
| Beta (5-Year) | 0.87 | 1.00 | Lower volatility during market turbulence |
Source: Data based on SCHD holdings as of May 2023. Actual metrics may vary based on future portfolio changes.
Understanding how SCHD's sector allocation performs during economic downturns can help investors anticipate how the ETF might behave in future recessions.
| Sector | SCHD Allocation | 2020 COVID-19 Crash | 2008-2009 Financial Crisis | 2000-2002 Dot-Com Crash |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financials | 20.5% | -32.4% | -68.3% | -18.2% |
| Information Technology | 18.7% | -19.2% | -43.6% | -82.5% |
| Healthcare | 15.3% | -13.1% | -24.6% | +9.2% |
| Consumer Staples | 13.5% | -11.8% | -26.2% | +1.7% |
| Industrials | 11.2% | -27.3% | -48.5% | -27.6% |
| Energy | 8.5% | -50.2% | -35.8% | +13.2% |
| Other Sectors | 12.3% | -25.7% | -42.1% | -31.4% |
Note: Performance figures represent average sector drawdowns during each recession period. Current SCHD sector allocations may change over time.
The data reveals several key insights about how SCHD's sector composition affects its recession performance:
One of SCHD's key advantages during recessions is the relative stability of its dividend income stream, even when share prices decline.
-5.8%
Maximum year-over-year dividend reduction
+8.2%
Year-over-year dividend growth maintained
-25.3%
Estimated maximum dividend reduction
Comparing SCHD's dividend stability to other investment options during recessions:
| Investment | 2020 COVID-19 Crash | 2008-2009 Financial Crisis | Recovery Time for Dividends |
|---|---|---|---|
| SCHD | -5.8% | -25.3% (est.) | 1.5 years |
| S&P 500 (SPY) | -12.7% | -31.8% | 4.3 years |
| High Yield ETFs | -22.4% | -47.6% | 6.2 years |
| Dividend Aristocrats | +0.2% | -14.3% | 2.1 years |
Key Insight on Dividend Stability
During recessions, SCHD's focus on companies with strong dividend histories, reasonable payout ratios, and solid cash flows tends to result in more modest dividend cuts compared to the broader market. This can provide vital income stability for retirees and income-focused investors during periods when other income sources may be compromised.
Based on SCHD's historical performance during market downturns, several strategies can help investors maximize returns and minimize risks when using SCHD during recessionary periods.
Continuing to invest fixed amounts in SCHD throughout a recession can significantly enhance long-term returns by acquiring more shares at lower prices.
Example Scenario:
An investor who dollar-cost averaged $500/month into SCHD through the 2020 COVID-19 crash achieved a 24.3% higher return after 2 years compared to an investor who paused contributions during the downturn.
Recessions create opportunities to reinvest dividends at higher yields, accelerating long-term compounding and income growth.
Example Scenario:
An investor who reinvested dividends during the 2018-2019 market correction increased their income stream by 16.8% more after 3 years compared to an investor who took dividends as cash during the downturn.
Using SCHD as a defensive component in a broader portfolio can reduce overall volatility while maintaining income during recessions.
Example Portfolio:
A balanced portfolio with 40% SCHD, 30% total bond market, 20% international dividend stocks, and 10% short-term Treasury bills experienced 23% less drawdown during the 2020 crash than an all-equity portfolio.
Optimizing your SCHD position during the late stages of a recession can enhance returns during the eventual market recovery.
Example Scenario:
Investors who increased their SCHD allocation by 20% near the bottom of the 2020 COVID-19 crash achieved average returns that were 31.2% higher over the following year compared to those who maintained static allocations.
Comparing SCHD's recession performance to other popular defensive investment options helps investors make informed allocation decisions.
| Investment | Average Recession Drawdown | Income Stability | Recovery Strength | Inflation Protection |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SCHD | -32.1% |
|
|
|
| Treasury Bonds | +5.2% |
|
|
|
| Utilities ETFs | -28.5% |
|
|
|
| Gold | -5.8% |
|
|
|
| Cash/Money Market | +0.2% |
|
|
|
Optimal Defensive Allocation
The data suggests an optimal defensive allocation during recessions would include:
This diversified approach balances capital preservation with income generation and positions the portfolio for strong recovery as economic conditions improve.
While SCHD was launched in 2011 (after the 2008-2009 financial crisis), we can analyze its performance during more recent market stress periods. During the 2020 COVID-19 crash, SCHD experienced a maximum drawdown of approximately -35.7%, which was slightly better than the S&P 500's -34% decline. SCHD recovered to pre-crash levels within 6 months and maintained most of its dividend payments. Backtested data suggests SCHD's methodology would have experienced less severe drawdowns than the broader market during the 2008-2009 financial crisis.
SCHD's focus on companies with strong dividend histories and financial stability helps minimize dividend cuts during economic downturns. During the 2020 COVID-19 crash, SCHD's dividend declined by approximately 5.8% from peak to trough before recovering—significantly better than the broader market. Backtested data suggests SCHD's methodology would have experienced dividend reductions of about 25% during the 2008-2009 financial crisis, compared to over 30% for the S&P 500.
SCHD's recovery time depends on the severity of the recession. After the 2020 COVID-19 crash, SCHD returned to its pre-crash price level within approximately 6 months. Dividend recovery took slightly longer, with distributions returning to pre-crash levels within about 1.5 years. Based on backtested data for the 2008-2009 financial crisis, SCHD's methodology would have suggested a price recovery period of approximately 3.2 years and a dividend recovery period of about 4 years.
SCHD and bonds serve different roles during recessions. High-quality bonds (especially Treasury bonds) typically provide better capital preservation during acute market stress, often gaining value when stocks decline. However, SCHD generally offers stronger income generation, better inflation protection, and significantly higher recovery potential. The optimal approach for most investors is to hold both SCHD and bonds in proportions that match their risk tolerance and income needs.
For long-term investors, gradually increasing SCHD allocation during a recession can be beneficial, particularly if you're reinvesting dividends or have a multi-year time horizon. The higher yields typically available during market downturns can enhance long-term returns. However, this should be done gradually through dollar-cost averaging rather than trying to time the market bottom. Investors near or in retirement may want to maintain a more balanced allocation between SCHD and more defensive assets like bonds and cash.